loading classes

I am in a situation I do not understand and will attempt to explain it as
best as i can.

I have created a simple rmi "echo" client/server application straight from
one of the sun courses. it has a class echo.server that only rebinds echo objects to the rmi registry.

I can compile and properly the client server rmi process when the
interface, impl class, stubs/skeletons are all in the same application.jar.
my java command line looks like

java -cp application.jar echo.server

If I move these the remote interface, impl, stub/skeleton to a
library.jar. all compiles properly. However, I recieve unmarshing error Echo ClassNotFoundException when I attempt to run it.

java -cp library.jar;application.jar echo.server


Why would simply moving the remote things to a package that I can share amongst many applictions be disallowed? I

Can you provide a short list of what is in each of the JARs? Also, what class is not found that throws the ClassNotFoundException?

If everhting is in one jar all works fine.

In non-working scenario.
All classes are packaged in appropriate directory structure.

the applciation jar contains EchoServer.java at it's top.
1 2 import EchoApp.*; 3 import java.rmi.Naming; 4 5 public class EchoServer { 6 public static void main(String args[])throws Exception{ 7 8 // Create the servant 9 // instance for registration 10 EchoImpl echoRef = new EchoImpl(); 11 12 // Bind the object to the rmiregistry 13 Naming.rebind("Echo", echoRef); 14 15 System.out.println ("Echo object ready and bound to the name 'Echo'!"); 16 } 17 }



libary jar has a EchoApp Directory that contains the remote interface, implementation, stub/skeleton classes. rmic -v1.1

remote interface
1 package EchoApp; 2 import java.rmi.Remote; 3 import java.rmi.RemoteException; 4 5 public interface Echo extends Remote { 6 public String sayEcho(String myName) throws RemoteException; 7 }

Impl class

1 package EchoApp; 2 3 import java.rmi.RemoteException; 4 import java.rmi.server.UnicastRemoteObject; 5 6 public class EchoImpl extends UnicastRemoteObject implements Echo { 7 8 public EchoImpl() throws RemoteException {}; 9 10 public String sayEcho(String myName) { 11 return "\nHello " + myName + "!!\n"; 12 } 13 }

[ February 02, 2005: Message edited by: peter cooke ]
[ February 02, 2005: Message edited by: peter cooke ]

OK, I was able to run your example - what you need to do is set the codebase property for your server. The ClassNotFoundException is thrown because the RmiRegistry can't find your stub to save in the registry. All you have to do is change your command line to look something like -

C:\source\echo\lib>start java -cp library.jar;application.jar -Djava.rmi.server.codebase="file:///C:/source/echo/lib/library.jar" EchoServer

(NEP - edited to break up really long command prompt line.)
[ February 03, 2005: Message edited by: Nathan Pruett ]

Nathan thanks so much. Have one last question.
Ok I found the documentation on sun about codebase.

Would you happen to know the reason why I must specify the codebase?
[ February 03, 2005: Message edited by: peter cooke ]

Section 3.2 in this RMI documentation gives a pretty good description.

Basically, codebase is kind of like a classpath for the remote code. If a client can't load a class in it's local classpath, it will look in the server's codebase for it.

Nearly three years later but just wanted to say thanks to Nate for answering this...

I had the exact same problem (worked unjar'd, threw the classNotFound when the application was jar'd). Interesting though, Sun says you don't need a codebase if you're using 1.5 (which I am). How come I needed the codebase afterall?

Sun's example and explanation

Note: If the server needs to support clients running on pre-5.0 VMs, then a stub class for the remote object implementation class needs to be pregenerated using the rmic compiler, and that stub class needs to be made available for clients to download. See the codebase tutorial for more details.